Cake & Cupcake Menu
Preservative free & made from scratch!
Wedding Cakes available, too!

~All serving amounts based on standard party serving size of 1.5” x 2” x 4”

6” 8-10 servings 8” 15-20 servings 9” 25-28 servings

~All pricing includes writing on top of cake, rosettes and piped border. See below for extras. I can add almond or lemon extracts to the vanilla sour cream or White vanilla at no extra cost.

~Custom Cupcakes and Cakes are available. Prices based on design.

~Vegan and gluten-free options available. **

Cupcakes -

1 dozen minimum $42.00/dozen

Chocolate Cake -

Moist, dark chocolate buttermilk cake with choice of dark chocolate frosting or vanilla Italian buttercream.

6" - $45.00  8" - $53.00  9" - $60.00

Vanilla Sour Cream Cake -

Vanilla cake filled and topped with your choice of dark chocolate frosting or vanilla Italian buttercream.

6" - $45.00  8" - $53.00  9" - $60.00

Coconut Cream Layer Cake -
aka Coco Crazy Cake

Coconut cake layers filled with coconut cream filling; coconut buttercream & covered with coconut Italian buttercream & toasted coconut.

6" - $65.00  8" - $75.00  9" - $85.00

Butterbug’s Extras:

~ Want to add filling
   or specialty frosting?

Filling choices: Strawberry, blueberry, raspberry, lemon curd. Specialty frostings: Chocolate ganache; strawberry, raspberry, cream cheese, or blueberry buttercream.

6" - add $10.00  8" - add $12.00  9" - add $15.00

~ Want to add a pop of color?

We have lots of Sprinkles and edible glitter to choose from!

add $5.00 - $10.00 per cake. We can do special sprinkle designs for additional cost.

~ Want extra decorations (extra flowers, special border)?

6" - add $8.00min  8" - add $10.00min  9" - add $12.00min

** Butterbug’s® is not a gluten free bakery. However, we take extra steps to reduce cross contamination, but we cannot guarantee a 100% sterile gluten-free product.

• We can make our Chocolate cake vegan and offer a Vegan vanilla cake as well.
  Pricing is $10 more per cake and $10 more per dozen cupcakes.

White vanilla cake -

Egg white vanilla cake filled and topped with your choice of dark chocolate frosting (my favorite combo!) or Vanilla Italian Buttercream.

6" - $45.00  8" - $53.00  9" - $60.00

Cupcakes -

1 dozen minimum $42.00/dozen

Cupcakes -

1 dozen minimum $42.00/dozen

Coconut cream Filled Cupcakes -

1 dozen minimum $48.00/dozen

Chocolate Spliff Cake -

Lightly spiced black pepper chocolate cake, filled with house-made lemon-thyme pastry cream, rolled up and coated with bittersweet chocolate ganache then dusted with cocoa-cayenne powder. Comes with a bag of my amazing chocolate-cayenne sauce for drizzling.

Half roll – serves up to 6 $50.00, Full roll serves from 10-15 $85.00

Lemon-thyme pastry filled cupcakes -

1 dozen minimum $50.00/doze

Aunt Valentyna’s Italian Cream Cake -

My Aunt Valentyna’s recipe! Moist coconut pecan cake with cream cheese frosting and filling. Garnished with toasted pecans.

6" - $65.00  8" - $75.00  9" - $85.00

Cupcakes -

1 dozen minimum $45.00/dozen

German Chocolate Cake -

Moist, dark chocolate buttermilk cake layered with house-made coconut pecan cream filling and topping. ****Please specify if you’d like the cake with or without chocolate frosting on the sides.

6" - $65.00  8" - $75.00  9" - $85.00

Coconut pecan cream Filled Cupcakes -

1 dozen minimum $48.00/dozen

Black Forest Cake -
**contains cherry liquor**

Moist, dark chocolate cake layers soaked with cherry liquor, filled with brandy-soaked cherries & sweetened whipped cream. Coated with whipped cream & chocolate shavings. Topped with brandied cherries & whipped cream.

6" - $68.00  8" - $78.00  9" - $88.00

Cupcakes -

1 dozen min. $50.00/dozen- cherry liquor soaked, Whipped cream, shaved chocolate and brandied cherry topped. Special pleated cupcake liners are used to enable liquor soak.

Gluten-free/Vegan Information:

We can make any of our cakes gluten free except for the chocolate spliff cake.
Please order 96 hours/four (4) business days in advance.

ORDERING: Please place your orders a minimum of 72 hours in advance by texting 828-712-9402 or emailing me at wendi@butterbugs.com. We make everything to order and require payment upon ordering thru secure payment link we send to your email.

Topped with chocolate ganache and cocoa-cayenne dusting

Pricing is $10 more per cake and $10 more per dozen cupcakes.